How to Tell If a Website Is Legit Before Buying (FTC Red Flags to Check)

Search the store's name with "scam" or "complaint," type the address yourself, and pay by credit card, because the FTC says a padlock and a top search spot prove nothing.

By Sophia · Updated November 2026 · Pulled from the FTC’s own consumer alerts and shopping guidance, read this week; nothing sponsored.

To tell if a website is legit before buying, search the store’s name plus “scam,” “complaint” or “review,” type the address in yourself instead of clicking an ad, and pay only with a credit card. If the site wants a gift card, wire transfer, payment app or crypto, walk away. That’s most of it. The rest is knowing which “trust signals” are fake.

This matters more than usual right now. On November 19, 2026, the FTC put out a fresh alert warning that scammers are buying search ads that sit right next to real retailers’ ads during the holiday rush. So the top result for “cheap stand mixer” might be the problem.

The five-minute check I’d run before any unfamiliar store

None of this needs software. You need a search bar and a little patience.

  1. Search the store name with the words “scam,” “complaint” and “review.” The FTC recommends exactly this, and it’s the single fastest filter. If other shoppers got burned, they usually say so loudly.
  2. Search the exact web address too, not only the brand name. The FTC says scammers sometimes impersonate real companies, so the address is what you’re vetting.
  3. Read the return policy before you add anything to the cart. Who pays return shipping? How many days do you get? Any restocking fee? A real store answers those plainly.
  4. Look at the shipping promise. If there’s no date at all, you should still know the rule (more on that below).
  5. Check how they want to be paid. This is the deal-breaker, so it gets its own section.

If a store fails step one, you’re done. Don’t argue yourself back into it because the price is good.

Red flags that a shopping site is fake

Some of these are obvious once you see them written down. Others look like safety features and aren’t.

Brand-name stuff at a price that makes no sense

The FTC’s online shopping guide puts it bluntly: expensive brand-name items offered at bargain prices could be counterfeit or stolen. A real 20% off on a pricey jacket during Black Friday week is normal. Seventy percent off a current-season designer bag from a store you found yesterday is not.

If you want to know what a normal sale price looks like, I wrote up how to tell if a Black Friday deal is actually good, and a price tracker will show you the price history in seconds.

You found it through a social media ad

Per the FTC’s 2025 holiday alert, scammers “camp out online all year long,” especially on social media, and sometimes impersonate real companies with ads for brand-name products at unusually low prices. Click through and you might get a knockoff, something that looks nothing like the photo, or nothing.

Ads aren’t automatically bad. Treat one as the start of your research and keep going.

It was the top sponsored search result

This is the one people don’t expect. The FTC’s November 2026 alert says scam ads can show up right next to legitimate companies’ ads, sometimes at the very top of the page. Its advice is to scroll past the paid results to the regular ones, which are ranked by relevance rather than by who paid the most. Or skip search entirely and type the store’s address into your browser if you already know it.

The padlock (it proves less than you think)

Yes, look for https at the start of the address. But the FTC is clear that the “s” only means the connection is encrypted. It doesn’t mean the site is legitimate, because scammers know how to encrypt sites too. A padlock on a fake store is still a fake store.

Reviews that are all five stars

The FTC warns against relying on star ratings alone because some reviews and ratings are fake or misleading. I’d read the three-star ones. They tend to be written by actual people with actual complaints about sizing or shipping, which is oddly reassuring.

“Comparison” sites that only show certain sellers

Some sites that rank or list products only include sellers who pay them, according to the FTC. That doesn’t make every comparison site shady. It does mean a “best price” badge from a site you’ve never heard of isn’t proof of anything.

How you pay is the real safety net

Here’s where I get opinionated. Even if you misjudge a site, the right payment method can get your money back. The wrong one usually can’t.

The FTC says paying by credit card best protects you if there’s a scam or something else goes wrong. With a credit card, you can dispute a charge if you’re billed twice, charged for something you never got, or sent the wrong or a damaged item.

The flip side matters just as much. If a seller says you can only pay by gift card, wire transfer, payment app or cryptocurrency, the FTC’s 2025 holiday alert says it’s probably a scam. Those methods make it hard to get money back, and that’s exactly why scammers ask for them.

Payment method What the FTC says
Credit card Best protection; you can dispute charges for items never received or billing errors
Gift card Never pay a seller this way; a classic scam request
Wire transfer (Western Union, MoneyGram) Never; hard to get money back
Payment app A seller who insists on it is probably a scammer
Cryptocurrency Same warning as above

Speaking of gift cards, if you’re buying them as presents this year, it’s worth knowing how to check a gift card for tampering before you hand one over.

The shipping rule most people don’t know

Sellers have to ship by the time they or their ads say they will. And if a seller doesn’t promise a time at all, the FTC says it has to ship your order within 30 days after it gets your name, address and payment (or your permission to charge you). If it can’t, you get a chance to cancel and get your money back.

So a store that takes your money and goes quiet for five weeks is breaking a federal rule, and you can say so.

What to do if you already bought from a sketchy site

Don’t panic. Do move fast.

First, gather your records. The FTC suggests keeping the company name and web address, your order details, the return policy, the shipping promise, every email or chat, and your card statement. Screenshots count.

Second, try the seller directly. If it’s a real (just badly run) business, this sometimes works.

Third, if that fails and you paid by credit card, dispute the charge. The FTC’s guidance is to call your card company right away and send a letter that reaches it within 60 days of the date it mailed you the first bill showing the problem. Sixty days goes faster than you’d think in December, so don’t wait for the new year.

Finally, report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. It won’t refund you on its own, but it’s how the FTC spots patterns. And for perspective, the FTC noted that in 2022, online shopping scams were the second-most reported type of scam it received. You’re not the first person this happened to.

If the order was real but the item just turned out wrong, that’s a returns problem instead. My rundown of holiday return deadlines at the big stores covers that.

Mistakes to skip

  • Trusting the padlock icon as proof a store is real.
  • Clicking the first sponsored result for a hot deal instead of scrolling or typing the address.
  • Paying with a gift card, wire transfer or payment app at a store you can’t vouch for.
  • Deleting the order confirmation email after the package “should” have arrived.
  • Waiting until January to dispute a charge from November.
  • Buying from a store only because a social media ad made the price look urgent.

Anyway. Most stores are fine. The point is to spend five minutes on the ones you’ve never heard of, especially this week, when Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals make everyone a little less careful.

FAQ

How can I tell if a website is legit before buying?

Search the store name and web address with words like “scam,” “complaint” and “review,” and read the return and shipping policies before checking out. Type the address yourself instead of clicking an ad. Then pay with a credit card so you can dispute the charge if anything goes wrong.

Does https mean a shopping site is safe?

No. The FTC says the “s” in https means the site is encrypted. It doesn’t prove the site is legitimate, since scammers can encrypt sites too. Treat it as the bare minimum, never as proof.

What’s the safest way to pay at an online store I don’t know?

A credit card. The FTC says it gives you the most protection, including the right to dispute charges for things you never got. Never pay an unfamiliar seller with a gift card, wire transfer, payment app or cryptocurrency.

What should I do if I ordered from a fake website?

Save every record of the order, contact the seller, and if that goes nowhere, dispute the charge with your credit card company. The FTC says your letter should reach the card company within 60 days of the first bill showing the error. Report the site at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

How long does an online store have to ship my order?

As long as it promised. If it didn’t promise any time, the FTC says it has to ship within 30 days of getting your order details and payment, or give you the chance to cancel and get your money back.

Are sponsored search results safe to click for holiday deals?

Not always. The FTC’s November 2026 alert says scam ads can appear next to real retailers’ ads and even at the top of results. Scroll down to the regular results or type the store’s address directly.

Sources: FTC, holiday search result scams (Nov 2026); FTC, avoiding online shopping scams this holiday season; FTC, Online Shopping guide; FTC, what to do when online shopping goes wrong.

If a store’s prices feel like a dare, they probably are. — Sophia

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Leave a Reply

Have a question or a useful shopping tip? Share it below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


✉ Get the Best Shopping Tips in Your Inbox

Helpful buying guides, honest reviews and gift ideas delivered to you.