8 Best Eyebrow Pencils 2025: Affordable and Tested

Once your eyebrows are done, the face is all framed, even without any heavy makeup on. That’s why I seek the best eyebrow pencil that gives a hair-like finish.

The days for precisely thin-lined and dark brows are gone. Natural, brushed-up, and fluffy brows are the current trend. The emphasis on achieving natural brows depends on using a good eyebrow pencil. 

But with so many options available in the market, which is the best? Let me help you with this! 

Here, I have shared my review on the top 8 best eyebrow pencils I have been using for the last one year. I have tested them every way possible to share my opinion with you. So, keep on reading to find out the best affordable eyebrow pencils.

My Top Picks of 2025

• Benefit Cosmetics- Precisely, My Brow Detailer– $26.00
• Anastasia Beverly Hills- Brow Wiz Pencil– $25
• Rare Beauty- Brow Harmony Precision Eyebrow Pencil– $19
• MAC- Pro Brow Definer Pencil– $24
• Kosas- Defining Eyebrow Pencil– $25
• CoverGirl- Micro-Fine + Define Pencil– $7
• L’Oréal Paris- Brow Stylist Eyebrow Pencil– $10.99
• Charlotte Tilbury- Brow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil– $26

Review of the 8 Best Eyebrow Pencils

As a beauty specialist and makeup lover, brows play a big role for me. It enhances my facial features more. You can go bold or keep it natural. As I experimented with brows for a long time, I tried different products. These are my top favourite and best eyebrow pencil list of 2025.

I have tried and tested them during the day, nighttime, gym, and even went swimming. Here’s my honest review of why they are my favourite:

1. Benefit Cosmetics- Precisely, My Brow Detailer

This eyebrow pencil is a good product overall. If you do not want to overdo the brows or smudge, you will surely love this. The ultra-precise tips will allow you to draw thin lines and give the brows a hair-like texture. It stays flawless for a straight 12 hours, without budging or smudging. 

Formula	Ingredients	Shades	Waterproof	Spoolie	Cruelty-Free
Wax	Synthetic Japan waxJojoba esters Castor oil Vitamin E	6	✔	✔	✘

2. Anastasia Beverly Hills- Brow Wiz Pencil

This product is one of the best-selling products from the brand. The brow pencil has proved why it is considered the GOAT in the beauty industry. The delicate tip and detailed strokes helped me to mimic my natural brow shape. I highly recommend this Anastasia Beverly Hills brow pencil for beginners as well as experts. 

The end results? Natural, fuller, defined, and perfect!

Formula	Ingredients	Shades	Waterproof	Spoolie	Cruelty-Free
Wax	Soybean oilGlycerin Carnauba Wax	12	✔	✔	✔

3. Rare Beauty- Brow Harmony Precision Eyebrow Pencil

This product got into my Best Eyebrow Pencil for its super creamy and perfectly blendable texture. It allowed me to diffuse the colour blend effortlessly while making the brows look natural. With a makeup remover, you can easily remove it. 

It is best to fill any gaps in your brows. Also, the creamy texture requires light hands to avoid any harsh lines. 

Formula	Ingredients	Shades	Waterproof	Spoolie	Cruelty-Free
Wax	Soybean oil Synthetic Japan wax	6	✔	✔	✔

4. MAC- Pro Brow Definer Pencil

When they claim this brow pencil stays, they mean it refuses to smudge a line unless you rub with a makeup remover. It is my perfect choice whenever I go for a gym session or swim. 

The precise pencil has an easy-to-blend formula. However, if you like bolder eyebrows, you may want a little more pigment. You will definitely get a fuller and natural look for any daytime function. 

The best thing is that it is filled with all-natural ingredients that help you get healthy eyebrow hairs. 

Formula	Ingredients	Shades	Waterproof	Spoolie	Cruelty-Free
Wax	Carnauba waxCastor ArganCoconut oils	14	✔	✔	✘

5. Kosas- Defining Eyebrow Pencil

If you are a newbie, this eyebrow pencil is a safe bet. The creamy, light texture glides on smoothly without giving any harsh lines. I prefer the thin, triangular-shaped tips that help with the versatile strokes. It is another ideal choice for beginners to get that all-natural and everyday eyebrow look. 

The only thing I noticed is that it fades a little after heavy workout sessions or over 8 to 9 hours. I needed to go for a touch-up before another separate event. 

Formula	Ingredients	Shades	Waterproof	Spoolie	Cruelty-Free
Wax	Castor oil Panthenol Provitamin B5	10	✘	✔	✔

6. CoverGirl- Micro-Fine + Define Pencil

CoverGirl Micro-Fine + Define pencil is the best and affordable eyebrow pencil. If you have a tight budget, just go for it without any second thought. You can easily get precise and well-defined eyebrows. The micro-fine tip is a bonus for the price that you have to pay. 

Formula	Ingredients	Shades	Waterproof	Spoolie	Cruelty-Free
Wax	Synthetic waxCottonseed oilVegetable oil	4	✔	✔	✔

7. L’Oréal Paris- Brow Stylist Eyebrow Pencil

This is also another best affordable eyebrow pencils. This best eyebrow pencil is a no-frills budget pick of my eyebrow pencil list. You will be well-equipped with the superpower of a skinny twist-up tip. Beginners can easily create natural, hair-like brows. 

The good thing for newbies is that the formula is slightly drier than the other pencils and glides on smoothly. It is hard to go overboard with this. I will absolutely rebuy it!

Formula	Ingredients	Shades	Waterproof	Spoolie	Cruelty-Free
Wax	Synthetic Japan waxSunflower seed oil	10	✔	✔	✘

8. Charlotte Tilbury- Brow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil

If you can extend your budget a little more, this eyebrow pencil can be a great investment. The luxurious packaging has my heart! It glides flawlessly, and every stroke has the right amount of pigment to get that hair-like finish. 

This pencil’s superpower is its refillable packet. This makes it an eco-friendly option and a great bang for your makeup pouch. 

Formula	Ingredients	Shades	Waterproof	Spoolie	Cruelty-Free
Wax	Microcrystalline waxSoybean oilVegetable oil	8	✔	✔	✔

5 Factors that Make the Best Eyebrow Pencil

The best eyebrow pencil is defined based on a few crucial factors. For me, investment in the best products always matters. Here are the top 5 factors that you can also consider to choose the ideal eyebrow pencil according to your preferences:

• Formula & Shades

The formula is the key. If you are an expert, working with any type of formula is your expertise. However, for beginners, understanding the formula based on the preference is essential. You should go for something you are comfortable working with; it can be wax, powder, or creamy. 

You must choose a shade that matches your natural hair colour. Considering your natural eyebrow hairs, you should go for warm or cool undertones. 

• Brow Type

To become a pro and get that natural eyebrow look, you must recognise your eyebrow type. A thin tip is best for creating natural strokes, whereas a thicker triangular tip is great for a defined and fuller look. 

• Long-lasting Wear

The best eyebrow pencil should offer long-lasting wear. A waxy, waterproof formula is ideal for long hours and all-day wear. For a short night out, you can go for a powder-based formula. 

However, I recommend that you avoid powdery formulas if you are prone to excessive sweating or live in a humid climate. 

• Pencil Tip

Choosing the ideal eyebrow pencil also includes consideration of the pencil tip. Note if the pencil is retractable or requires sharpening. Here is how you can choose:

Thin or Pointed Tip– Precision 

Flat and Broader Side– Fuller Coverage 

• Additional Features

Lastly, the best eyebrow pencil should come with additional features such as a sharpener for pencils that require sharpening. An attached spoolie is a must-have for seamless blending. 

Takeaways 

I have tested many eyebrow pencils over the past years and found the 8 best eyebrow pencils that I will definitely recommend to you. You can find affordable options as well as some luxurious investments that are totally worth every penny. The Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Detailer is my top pick among this list. 

Hope my review and recommendations have been helpful for you to choose the ideal eyebrow pencil. No matter if you are a beginner or a pro, I have shared something for everyone. 

So, which one is your favourite eyebrow pencil? Do not forget to share through the comment box below. Till then, go make a statement with your perfect brows! 

Frequently Asked Questions