Is Regifting Rude? The Etiquette Rules for Passing On a Gift

Regifting is fine when the item is new, complete, not personalized and a real fit for the new person, and here are the Emily Post rules plus how to handle gift cards.

By Sophia · Updated November 2026 · Pulled from the Emily Post Institute, the CFPB and published Bankrate and Empower surveys; nothing sponsored

Is regifting rude? Not when you follow a few rules: the item is brand new and complete, it isn’t handmade or personalized, you’re confident the new person will actually like it, and nobody involved would be hurt to find out. Break any of those and yes, it can sting. Follow them and you’re in good company, because the Emily Post Institute is fine with it.

Plenty of people already do it. A Bankrate column from December 2024 cited Bankrate survey figures showing 30% of Americans have regifted a holiday present and one in three say regifting holiday gifts is acceptable. Empower’s “Gifted” study, reported the same month, found 42% of Americans planned to regift to keep costs down.

So you’re allowed. The skill is doing it in a way that reads as thoughtful.

When regifting is perfectly fine

Lizzie Post, co-president of the Emily Post Institute, wrote in her AARP “Money Manners” column that regifting “can be a beautiful thing when handled with care.” She gives two situations that are clearly okay.

The first is when you already own the thing. You got a second air fryer, a duplicate book or a candle in a scent you already burn, and you know someone who’d love it. That’s a good match, and nobody loses.

The second is passing on something you’ve loved for years, like a watch, a piece of art or a keepsake, to someone close to you when you’re ready to let it go. That’s closer to an heirloom than a regift, honestly.

The Emily Post Institute’s own regifting page adds a practical example: your sister’s coffeemaker dies right before her birthday, you have a spare new one sitting in its box, and you hand it over. She’s thrilled. Done.

The regifting rules, in plain terms

If you’re going to pass something along without saying where it came from, Lizzie Post lays out four rules. I’ve put them in my own words:

  • It’s complete and in its original packaging, with every part, cord and manual.
  • It isn’t handmade, one of a kind, monogrammed or personalized, even if the initials happen to match.
  • You’re nearly certain neither the original giver nor the new recipient would be upset to learn it was regifted.
  • You actually believe the new person will enjoy it.

She calls that last one the most important rule and the one people forget most. I agree. A regift that suits the person feels like a gift. A regift that suits your closet space feels like a chore you handed off.

The Emily Post Institute’s page adds one more filter that I find useful: think about whether the original giver put real care into choosing it. A generic gift set from a work exchange is fair game. The scarf your aunt spent an afternoon picking out for you is not.

What you should never regift

Some items are off the table no matter how careful you are.

Handmade or personalized things. Both Emily Post sources say this outright. A knitted hat or an engraved flask has someone’s effort or your name built into it.

Anything used, opened or missing pieces. If you tried the face cream once, it’s yours now. The Emily Post page says a regift should be brand new and still have its packaging and instructions.

Gifts back to the person who gave them. Lizzie Post singles this out as a real misstep. It happens more than you’d think when someone forgets who gave what, so keep track (a quick note on your phone works).

“Convenience regifts.” That’s Lizzie Post’s term for giving something mainly to get rid of it. If the honest reason is “I don’t want this,” the recipient probably won’t want it either.

Anything with a card, tag or message still tucked inside. Check every pocket of the box before you wrap it. This is the classic way people get caught.

Should you tell them it’s a regift?

You don’t have to. But being upfront takes almost all the risk out.

The Emily Post Institute’s page points out that wrapping a regift and presenting it as something you shopped for is a bit deceptive, and that people can see it as lazy if they find out later. The fix is simple: say it. Its example line is “Ellie, I received two copies of this book and want you to have one.” Lizzie Post’s version for AARP is “Alex, I received this as a gift. However, I already own it, and I really thought you’d enjoy it.”

Notice what both lines do. They explain why this person, and why this item. That turns a hand-me-down into a small, honest gesture.

The Emily Post page also suggests giving this kind of pass-along as an unwrapped, unofficial surprise rather than as your main holiday gift. I think that’s smart. Keep the regift for a “saw this and thought of you” moment and buy or make the actual Christmas present.

Can you regift a gift card?

Yes, and it’s one of the easiest things to pass on, since a balance is a balance. Bankrate’s 2024 data cited in that same column found 43% of Americans had an unused gift card, voucher or store credit, and 8% had regifted a gift card.

A few checks before you hand one over:

  • Confirm the balance first, on the retailer’s site or by phone. Giving someone a card that turns out to be empty is worse than giving nothing.
  • Look at fees and dates. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says federal rules bar inactivity or service fees on gift cards for the first 12 months, but fees can start after that and slowly eat the balance. A gift card also generally can’t be sold if it expires in under five years.
  • Know the exceptions. The CFPB notes that reloadable prepaid cards not sold as gift cards may not be covered, so fees can start right away.
  • Pass along the terms and any receipt if you still have them, which the CFPB recommends when giving a card.

And if the card has been sitting in a drawer since last year, look it over the way you would a new one. My guide on how to check a gift card for tampering covers what to look at.

Regift, return or donate?

Regifting isn’t your only option, and sometimes it’s the worst one.

Situation Better move
New, complete, and you know someone who’d love it Regift, ideally with an honest one-liner
New, but nobody you know wants it Return or exchange it, if you have a gift receipt
A duplicate of something you already own Regift or return, whichever is easier
Kids’ toys you’ve got doubles of A toy drive
Handmade, personalized or opened Keep it, or donate it if it’s still usable

If you got a gift receipt, that’s often the cleanest path. Here’s how gift receipts work at Amazon, Target, Best Buy and Macy’s, and the holiday return deadlines at the big stores so you don’t miss the window.

The toy drive idea isn’t mine, by the way. A Bankrate writer, Ryan Flanigan, said in that December 2024 column that when his son got repeat toys, “we opted to give them to a toy drive instead.” Good call.

Regifting at a white elephant or Secret Santa

Office swaps are where regifting feels most tempting and where you need the most care. Coworkers talk, and the person who gave you that gift might be sitting two desks away.

My rule: only regift into an exchange if the item is new, generic, clearly fits the group’s price limit and didn’t come from anyone in that same group. A sealed board game you got twice? Fine. Last year’s swap gift, brought back to the same office? Skip it.

If you’d rather just buy something, I’ve got a list of Secret Santa gifts under $25 people actually use.

Mistakes that get people caught

Most regifting disasters are small, avoidable slips. Watch for these:

  • Leaving the original gift tag, card or a “To: You” sticker inside the packaging.
  • Rewrapping in a box with a store’s holiday sleeve from a city you don’t live in.
  • Giving it within the same friend group, family branch or office as the original giver.
  • Passing on something dated, like a calendar for the year that’s ending.
  • Forgetting who gave it to you, then giving it right back.

Anyway. If you’re unsure, the Emily Post Institute’s advice is short: don’t regift.

FAQ

Is regifting rude?

Regifting isn’t rude when the item is new, complete, not personalized and a real fit for the new person. The Emily Post Institute says it’s acceptable under those conditions. It becomes rude when you pass along something used, handmade or chosen mainly to clear space.

Is it okay to regift something you already own?

Yes. Lizzie Post of the Emily Post Institute names this as one of the clearest cases where regifting is fine. Keep the new one in its box and give it to someone who’ll use it.

Do you have to tell someone a gift is regifted?

No, but it helps. A short line like “I got two of these and thought of you” removes any awkwardness if they find out later. The Emily Post Institute notes that presenting a regift as something you shopped for can feel deceptive.

Can you regift a gift card?

Yes. Check the balance first and look for fees, since the CFPB says inactivity fees can start after 12 months. Reloadable prepaid cards that weren’t sold as gift cards may not have the same federal protections.

What should you never regift?

Handmade items, anything monogrammed or engraved, opened or used products, and gifts with missing parts. Never give a gift back to the person who gave it to you, which Lizzie Post calls a real misstep.

If you’re shopping fresh instead, my list of gifts for people who have everything is a decent place to start.

Sources: Emily Post Institute on regifting, Lizzie Post’s AARP Money Manners column, CFPB on gift card terms, Bankrate’s regifting column via Stars and Stripes, Empower survey coverage on KTVU.

Just check the box for a card before you wrap it. Every time. — Sophia

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Leave a Reply

Have a question or a useful shopping tip? Share it below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


✉ Get the Best Shopping Tips in Your Inbox

Helpful buying guides, honest reviews and gift ideas delivered to you.