How to Check a Gift Card for Tampering Before You Give It

Check the packaging, feel the barcode for a sticker, make sure the PIN is covered and open the envelope before you leave the store, because drained gift cards are a real holiday scam.

By Sophia · Updated November 2026 · Pulled from FTC, CFPB and BBB guidance plus police warnings reported in the news; nothing sponsored

To check a gift card for tampering, look at the packaging for tears, wrinkles or resealed edges, run your finger over the barcode to feel for a stuck-on sticker, and make sure the PIN is still covered. Then open the envelope before you leave the store and confirm the card is actually inside. That last step takes ten seconds and it’s the one most people skip.

Gift cards are an easy holiday gift, which is exactly why thieves like them. The scams aren’t sophisticated. They just count on you grabbing a card off the rack, paying, and handing it over sealed three weeks later, long after the money’s gone.

How gift card tampering actually works

There are three main versions, and they all happen before you ever touch the card.

The first is the number grab. According to the Better Business Bureau, scammers use handheld scanners in stores to capture card details, then check the balance through the retailer’s 800 number. Once you activate the card at the register, they spend it online or move the money to their own cards. The FTC described the same pattern in December 2024: thieves peel off protective stickers or scratch the back to get the number and PIN, put the card back, and wait.

The second is the barcode swap. The BBB’s Scam Tracker has a report of a sticker placed over the barcode through the little window in the packaging. The cashier scanned the sticker, the money loaded onto the scammer’s card, and the buyer walked out with a card that had nothing on it.

The third is the cut card. Police in Pinole, California, told 6abc that because the barcode the register scans sits on the outside of the envelope, scammers can slice away the part of the card you need to spend it and leave the rest on the shelf. Sgt. Barry Duggan also described thieves heating envelopes to open them and pull the card out.

Different tricks. Same result.

How to check a gift card for tampering in the store

None of this needs special skills. It does need you to slow down for about thirty seconds at the rack, which I know is a big ask in mid-December.

  1. Pick a card from the back or middle of the rack rather than the front one everybody’s handled. (That’s my habit, not an official rule, but it costs nothing.)
  2. Look over the packaging for tears, wrinkles, glue marks or edges that seem resealed. The BBB specifically says to check whether the PIN or barcode is exposed.
  3. Run a finger across the barcode. A sticker on top of it usually feels raised or slightly off-square.
  4. Check that the scratch-off strip or PIN sticker on the back is intact. If it’s scratched, scuffed or missing, put it down.
  5. After you pay, open the envelope at the register and confirm the card is there and whole. A Pinole Police Department spokesperson put it plainly: “Go ahead and open that card. Make sure that the barcode is there.”
  6. Keep the receipt with the card. The FTC says to save both, because they’re what you’ll need if the balance turns up empty.

If anything looks wrong, don’t just swap it for the card next to it. The FTC notes that scammers tend to tamper with cards in batches, so tell a cashier or manager and consider buying at a different store.

Is it safer to buy gift cards online?

Usually, yes. The BBB says buying online can be safer because you skip the physical cards that might have been handled on a shelf. The catch is that you have to buy from the retailer’s real website.

Be suspicious of any site or social media ad selling popular store cards at a steep discount. The BBB warns those can be fronts for stealing your payment card number or personal details. It also flagged a case where someone bought a gift card online for a restaurant that had already closed, and the site was still selling them.

And pay with a credit card if you can. The FTC points out that credit cards come with stronger protections, including the option to dispute the charge if the card turns out to be worthless.

What to do if the card has no balance

Act fast. Every day you wait is a day the trail goes colder.

Call the issuer using the phone number printed on the card or listed on the retailer’s official site. Have the card number and your receipt ready. The FTC’s gift card guidance says that depending on the issuer, you may be able to get some money back, which is a lot more hopeful than “it’s gone.”

Then report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If you paid by credit card and the issuer won’t help, that’s when a dispute with your card company makes sense.

One more thing on balances: don’t type the card number into a random “check your balance” website. The BBB says some of those ask for the number and PIN, which is all a thief needs.

Gift card rules worth knowing before you give one

Tampering is the scary part, but the fine print trips up more people. Here’s what federal rules cover, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

Question What the CFPB says
Can a gift card expire? Not in less than five years. If money is left when it expires, you can get a replacement card at no cost.
Can it charge inactivity fees? Not for the first 12 months. After that, fees can start eating into the balance.
Store card or Visa/Mastercard card? Store cards work only at that merchant or group. Network-branded cards work wherever the network is accepted.
Does this cover reloadable prepaid cards? No. If a card isn’t sold as a gift card, the gift card rules don’t apply and fees can start right away.

States can add stronger protections on top of these, so the card’s own terms are worth a glance.

The CFPB also suggests giving the terms and the receipt along with the card. That’s a nice touch, and it pairs well with a gift receipt for anything physical you’re wrapping alongside it. If the gift card is going to a coworker or your kid’s teacher, check the dollar limits first; I covered those in how much to spend on a teacher gift and gifts for your boss.

Mistakes to skip

A few habits make tampering scams work. Drop them.

  • Buying the card and leaving the envelope sealed until the party. You lose your best chance to catch a problem while you’re still at the store.
  • Tossing the receipt. Without it, proving what you loaded is a lot harder.
  • Buying discounted cards from auction sites or resellers you’ve never heard of. The FTC says to think twice, since those can be fake or stolen.
  • Letting the card sit in a drawer. The BBB says the longer it sits, the more likely someone steals the balance, so tell the recipient to register it if the retailer allows and to use it soon.
  • Picking a store that looks shaky. The BBB is blunt: “When a store goes out of business, its gift cards do too.”

And the big one, which isn’t about gifting at all. The FTC says anyone who demands payment by gift card, for any reason, is a scammer. The IRS, the utility company and a grandkid in trouble don’t take Target cards.

If you’re still filling out a list, my Secret Santa ideas under $25 are a decent backup plan when a gift card feels too impersonal.

FAQ

How can you tell if a gift card has been tampered with?

Look for torn, wrinkled or resealed packaging, an exposed PIN, a scratched security strip, or a sticker sitting on top of the barcode. Running your finger over the barcode is the quickest way to feel a stuck-on label. If something looks off, tell the cashier and pick a card from another store.

Should I open a gift card envelope before leaving the store?

Yes. Police in Pinole, California, recommend opening it at the register to make sure the full card and barcode are inside. Some scammers cut the usable part off and leave the scannable envelope behind, so a sealed package proves nothing.

Is it safer to buy gift cards online or in store?

The BBB says online can be safer because you avoid cards that may have been handled on a rack. Only buy from the retailer’s official website, and skip ads or sites offering big discounts on popular brands.

What happens if I buy a gift card with no money on it?

Contact the card issuer right away with the card and your receipt, and report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. The FTC says some issuers may refund part of the value. If you paid by credit card, you can also try disputing the charge.

Do gift cards expire?

Under federal rules, a gift card can’t be sold with an expiration date less than five years out, according to the CFPB. Inactivity fees also can’t kick in during the first 12 months. Reloadable prepaid cards that aren’t sold as gift cards follow different rules.

Thirty seconds at the register beats an awkward phone call in January. — Sophia

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Leave a Reply

Have a question or a useful shopping tip? Share it below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


✉ Get the Best Shopping Tips in Your Inbox

Helpful buying guides, honest reviews and gift ideas delivered to you.